I think this is a regrettable choice.
I understand why Plouffe was an attractive speaker for the 2009 convocation. He is the man behind a campaign which enjoyed strong support from Cornell students and faculty. (In The Cornell Progressive's final pre-election campus poll, 74 percent of students backed Obama.) Hundreds campaigned for him.
Slicklen writes in the press release:
The Class of 2009 sought an individual who has had a profound impact on the society that our class has been prepared to enter. Mr. Plouffe was the mastermind behind one of the most significant and groundbreaking elections in our nation's history.I disagree with none of this. However, the choice of an unquestionably partisan figure strikes me as inappropriate for this type of occasion. Convocation is not a political rally, and it should be noted that there are many on East Hill who opposed Obama's candidacy. If Slicklen's desire was merely to choose a successful public figure to deliver a motivational speech, there were plenty of nonpartisan options available. Imagine if five years ago the committee had brought Karl Rove to speak, yet attempted to mollify a rabid student body by promising that Rove wouldn't focus solely on politics.
As we find the student body -- at least those who write for the Sun -- divided on the Gaza issue, complete with dueling Arts Quad exhibits, Convocation provides a great opportunity to unite students with diverse perspectives. Plouffe, while certainly charismatic, was a major player in a lengthy, often negative presidential campaign, in which hundreds of millions of dollars were spent by both sides. He is celebrated as a hero by those of us who supported Obama, yet no doubt vilified by those who did not. Plouffe never attained a college degree, something the thousands of graduates in front of him worked hard to achieve, and has spent his adult life working for a succession of Democrats. I fail to see how his personal story, taken separate from partisan politics, is compelling.
I know that the search for a speaker began long before the Gaza issue captured students' attention, but bringing in someone as highly political and partisan as Plouffe spoils what would otherwise be a rare opportunity to bring the Cornell community together.